Recap: Western Michigan hangs on for 34-27 win over upset-minded Eastern Michigan

The Broncos are looking to stay atop the MAC in a thick title race while the Eagles are fighting for bowl eligibility.

Share
Recap: Western Michigan hangs on for 34-27 win over upset-minded Eastern Michigan
(Andrew Graham/Mitten Football)

KALAMAZOO — Western Michigan (7-3, 5-1 MAC) hosts Eastern Michigan (4-6, 3-3 MAC) with a chance to win outright the Michigan MAC trophy for the second straight year, with another dose of midweek MACtion.

The Broncos are also looking to keep pace in the MAC title race, staying at one loss in league play with the likes of Toledo, Buffalo and Ohio. 

Eastern Michigan, meanwhile, needs to win tonight to keep bowl hopes alive for a win-and-get-eligible game in Week 13. 

It’ll be a tall task for EMU, though, as starting quarterback Noah Kim is once again out, per the MAC availability report. It means one of Brogan McCaughey or Jace Stuckey will be starting at quarterback for the Eagles. 

Kickoff is set for 6 p.m. on ESPN2 from Waldo Stadium, as WMU looks to defend home turf and EMU hopes to keep its bowl dreams alive.


FINAL: Western Michigan 34, Eastern Michigan 27

A late flurry of first half scoring proved to be critical for Western Michigan (8-3, 6-1 MAC) in holding on to survive a furious comeback attempt from Eastern Michigan (4-7, 3-4 MAC) on Tuesday night at Waldo Stadium in an eventual 34-27 win. 

Western Michigan went into the half up 31-7, by virtue of a late two-minute drive touchdown and then a pick six by linebacker Dillon Moore in the final seconds of the first half. Jalen Buckley had paced the WMU offense, and made some history in the process, moving to third all-time on the WMU rushing touchdown list and fifth all-time in rushing yards. 

But the second half was defined by Eastern Michigan, switching out quarterback Jace Stuckey, who got the start, for Brogan McCaughey, who started the prior two games while preferred starter Noah Kim remained hurt. 

Where Stuckey struggled in the first half — EMU only scored on a one-play drive set up inside the WMU 10 by a muffed punt — McCaughey shined in the second, hitting throws out of structure and giving the EMU skills guys a chance. 

McCaughey finished 12-of-16 for 135 yards and a touchdown. 

And tailback Amareon Blue shined for EMU, the first EMU back to go over 100 yards on the year as he powered in three touchdowns, including a 41-yard score to open things up in the third quarter. 

But the Eagles ultimately ran out of time Western Michigan picked up just enough first downs, came up with a game-clinching sack at the death, and managed to stay atop the MAC standings.

WMU makes game-sealing sack on 4th and ballgame

EMU had a 4th and 7 from the WMU 22 with :39 to go, and Western Michigan DC Greer Martini cooked up a blitz, as Josh Franklin and Scoop Gardner Jr. got home.

WMU will win, 34-27.

Facemask moves EMU closer

McCaughey was trying to break out from the pocket and got his helmet ripped off, which will have EMU down to the WMU 25 with :58 left in the game.

WMU leads, 34-27.

Eagles quickly into WMU territory

Brogan McCaughey finds Josh Long in a soft spot over the middle and takes a big chunk to cross the 50. Took just three plays for EMU to get across the 50 yard line.

WMU ends up punting

It'll be EMU ball at the 23, so 77 yards to cover with 1:51 and one timeout for Brogan McCaughey and the rest of the Eagles.

Two minute warning: Western Michigan 34, Eastern Michigan 27

It'll be 4th and 7 at the EMU 43 yard line for the Broncos after the two minute stoppage. Chris Creighton has used two of his timeouts, so a first down effectively wins this for WMU, but seven yards is a long way to go.

It'll be an interesting decision for Lance Taylor out of the stoppage.

Bronco defense steps up, forces 3 and out

EMU will punt with the clock ticking under 5:00 to play from its own 28 after three plays couldn't move the sticks. With a full suite of timeouts, EMU has plenty of time to try and defend, get another stop, and get the ball back to tie the game.

WMU, now, has a chance to try and end the game on its terms and get more out of an offense that's mustered just three points since halftime.

34-27, WMU, with 4:47 to play.

EMU forces 3 and out

A perfect development for the Eagles, and the wrong type of series for the Broncos, as the WMU offesne burns just more than a minute of clock before punting back to the Eagles with 6:14 left.

Quinn Fracassi is slung down immediately as he fields the punt at the EMU 32. A block in the back call will have EMU starting at the minus 22, instead.

But with 6:14 to go, down 34-27, EMU has played this second half perfectly to have a shot late after going into half trailing 31-7.

Touchdown, WMU — Blue burrows in from 2 yards out

After entering halftime trailing by 24, Eastern Michigan is now down just a touchdown, outscoring WMU 20-3 through the first 22:24 of the second half.

And Blue is now up to three touchdown runs on the night, as he has a career day vs. the Broncos.

Brogan McCaughey has utterly changed the complexion of the EMU offense since entering at QB out of half, as EMU has scored touchdowns on all three second half drives. McCaughey is 8-of-9 for 103 yards and a touchdown.

But a time-chewing drive and a score here can make things a lot more comfortable for WMU in the final minutes.

It's 31-24, WMU, with 7:36 to play.

WMU kicks field goal

Eastern Michigan's defense comes up with a bend-don't-break set of downs there to bring out Dieter Kelly and cap a 14 play, 64 yard drive with a field goal. WMU did chew up eight minutes of clock on the drive, though.

Kelly is now 2-of-2 on field goals and WMU leads, 34-20, with 12:45 left in the game.

End of 3: Western Michigan 31, Eastern Michigan 20

It was a perfect response out of halftime for the Eagles, as head coach Chris Creighton swapped quarterbacks, going from Jace Stuckey to Brogan McCaughey and immediately getting paid off as McCaughey led two touchdown drives while going 6-of-7 for 76 yards and a touchdown, completing passes to Josh Long (including the the touchdown), Nick Devereaux and Harold Mack, letting the EMU playmakers go to work some.

Amareon Blue has also shined for EMU, ripping off a 41-yard touchdown run and going over 100 yards for the first time for and EMU back this year.

And with a 13-0 quarter — EMU went for two after the first touchdown to start the third quarter — it's now just a two score game, 31-20.

But, Western Michigan will have 1st and 10 at the EMU 16 yard line to open the fourth quarter, as a promising drive rolls on.

Buckley passes another historical threshold

Jalen Buckley is now the fifth all-time leading rusher in WMU history. He passes Brandon West with a chunk run through the middle to take WMU across midfield late in the third quarter vs. EMU.

Next up on the all-time rushing leaders list is Lavonte Bellamy, who Buckley is close to passing, too.

Buckley earlier tonight because WMU's third all-time rushing touchdown leader. He's got 13 carries for 127 yards and two touchdowns tonight — so far.

Touchdown, EMU — McCaughey connects with Long

The Eagles have had a perfect response out of halftime in this game, and have to be kicking themselves for the pick six.

Brogan McCaughey made another nice out of structure play to get Eastern down into scoring territory, then rolled right on 2nd and goal and found Josh Long in the back of the end zone to cap a nine play, 81 yard drive that took 4:06.

The 1 yard TD completion and PAT make it 31-20, WMU, with 5:53 left in the third quarter, as EMU has gone TD-stop-TD on the first three series out of half here.

Had the Eagles not given up the pick six just before halftime, this would be a one score game.

Blue takes EMU to midfield, crosses 100 yards

Amareon Blue's nice night continues, and a chunk run of 18 off right tackle takes him across 100 yards on the evening. He follows it up with another 10 to move the chains again and take the Eagles into WMU territory.

It's the first 100 yard rusher for EMU this year, as Blue is up to 18 carries for 125 yards and the touchdown.

EMU forces stop, punt

With a touchdown drive to start, now EMU forces a stop — and opens this half with a pitch perfect set of series to try and claw back and make this a game.

McCaughey continues at quarterback as the Eagles start at the minus 19.

Touchdown, EMU — McCaughey leads touchdown drive

Keyed by Brogan McCaughey rolling out to his left, being patient and hitting Harold Mack down the left sideline for a foot-dragging conversion on third down, EMU got out to midfield and then Amareon Blue catapulted through the middle and out to the right side for a 41-yard touchdown run.

EMU on one drive doubles up its yardage total, as the quarterback swap pans out. A two-point try is no good, as EMU sought to make it a two-score game. Instead it'll be 31-13 and a three-score margin.

There's 11:28 left in the third quarter.

EMU turns to McCaughey at QB out of half

The Eagles are swapping quarterbacks to open the second half, putting in Brogan McCaughey, who started vs. Ohio and Central Michigan, into the game.

This comes after the Eagles failed to gain 100 yards in the first half as Jace Stuckey, who started at QB, completed 6-of-9 passes for seven yards and threw a late pick six.

HALF: Western Michigan 31, Eastern Michigan 7

The Broncos have opened up a can on EMU, with two touchdowns within the final minute to turn a 10 point margin into a 24-point halftime lead.

And Eastern Michigan only scored on a one-play, eight-yard drive after recovering a muffed WMU punt inside the 10. Otherwise, Eastern Michigan has run 27 plays for 70 yards in the half. EMU has just seven passing yards, as junior quarterback Jace Stuckey has struggled to affect the game in his first start.

At the half, Stuckey is 6-of-9 for 7 yards and threw a pick six shortly before halftime. He's offered some ability to scramble, but not enough to jolt the Eagles alive. Amareon Blue has 51 yards on 12 carries, a lone bright spot for EMU.

Jalen Buckley opened the scoring for WMU, taking the first play from scrimmage 72 yards for a touchdown, then adding a one-yarder on WMU's second drive, moving him alone into third place all-time among WMU's rushing touchdown leaders, as it was the 40th of his career.

Buckley finished the first half with 10 carries for 107 yards.

Touchdown, WMU — Dillon Moore nabs last-second pick six

It's an eerily similar play to Dillon Moore's interception vs. Michigan in Week 1, where he just stepped out of bounds instead of taking it back for a score. But this time he jumps a backside route that Jace Stuckey threw, barreled down the home sideline, cut back inside of Stuckey and rumbled into the end zone with :02 left in the half.

The PAT makes it 31-7, and WMU has blown open a game that was 17-7 going into the two minute warning.

It's a 50 yard pick six for Moore, and his second interception of the year. And that's 17 unanswered points for WMU after the muffed punt handed EMU its lone touchdown.

Touchdown, WMU — Cabana caps off 2 minute drive

The Broncos took over at the minus 43, got the help of two EMU personal fouls — a facemask and a roughing call — to help wipe out a sack and then get into scoring range before Broc Lowry kept and took WMU inside the five, then Cabana pushed in for a two-yard score.

WMU covered 57 yards in five plays and 1:14 to push the lead to 24-7 with :40 until the half.

EMU will start the second half with the football.

Two minute warning: Western Michigan 17, Eastern Michigan 7

The Eagles have settled in on defense and made it quite a fight, and the offense managed to capitalize off the WMU muffed punt but otherwise hasn't been able to do anything.

QB Jace Stuckey, a junior making his first career start, is 3-of-5 for 1 yard through the air, but has made some progress with his legs, carrying three times for 22 yards on scrambles.

He did just take the first sack of the game for either team, as EMU will punt on 4th and 12 from deep in its own territory after the stoppage. EMU gets the ball to open the second half.

EMU's defense hedges the gamble, forces field goal

The Eagles might've gambled and lost, going on fourth down from the minus 24 and not getting it, but the defense forced a quick three-play stop and held WMU to a 36-yard field goal by Dieter Kelly.

It's Kelly's first field goal since WMU played Bowling Green on Halloween.

17-7, with 3:23 to halftime.

Eastern gambles on 4th down in own territory, gets stuff

Braydon Bennett took the wildcat direct snap with about a yard to go from the EMU 24 and go rolled up before he could get to the 25, and the Broncos take over with fantastic field position.

EMU head coach Chris Creighton took a timeout before the fourth down play, and opted to stay aggressive but go with Bennett, the power back, in a wildcat look. WMU, though, came up with the play.

WMU goes on 4th and goal, comes up empty

After Broc Lowry and Adam Parks can't connect on 3rd and goal from the 3, the Broncos keep the offense on the field and Lowry's 4th down attempt to the right side is a bit wide, high and well-contested by the EMU defense. Parks was the intended target on fourth down, too.

The third down play was wide open, but Lowry ended up throwing behind Parks, who ran a bit of a delayed route to come across the middle from Lowry's left. Against zone coverage, Lowry seemed to anticipate parks would settle on the third down play, while the tight end continued his route, making a catch difficult on what was a wide-open route.

It's a big stand for the Eagles, which will now send the offense out with 97 yards to go to find the end zone.

14-7, WMU, 9:00 to halftime.

End of 1: Western Michigan 14, Eastern Michigan 7

Eastern Michigan is on the board by virtue of a WMU special teams turnover to set up a one-play Amareon Blue touchdown drive, as the sophomore back scampered around the left side to win a race to the pylon.

That cut WMU's lead in half to 14-7 with around 2:30 to play in the first quarter.

Jalen Buckley had both touchdowns for WMU, including a 72-yard rushing touchdown on the first play from scrimmage. He punched in a one-yard on WMU's second drive to cap off a 93-yard march. The second score moved Buckley into third place alone on the all-time WMU rushing touchdown list, with 40 career scores on the ground.

WMU has the ball, 1st and 10 at the minus 43 when the second quarter begins.

WMU muffs punt inside 10, EMU gets one-play TD drive

EMU's second drive ended much like its first: Punting just shy of midfield.

But then WMU muffed a punt at the seven, the Eagles recovered, and Amareon Blue went around the left side to win a race to the pylon, putting EMU on the board.

It's 14-7 with the PAT, and suddenly the Eagles are alive in this one after capitalizing on the WMU miscue.

Touchdown, WMU — Broncos add to lead

Jalen Buckley moves to third all-time in WMU history in career rushing touchdowns, as he's now got 40 total in his five years at WMU.

It's already his second of the night, too, but this one came from one yard out as he bullied through the middle of the pile to push across the goal line.

WMU now leads, 14-0, with 6:12 remaining in the first quarter.

WMU up to 35 yards gained on penalties on 2nd drive

An early defensive pass interference saved WMU on a third down incompletion, and moved WMU 15 yards toward midfield. Then a pair of fouls on one play: A defensive hold and a dead ball penalty for a late hit on the scrambling Broc Lowry, a very questionable call.

It appears the refs got Makhi Gilbert for a little extra twist and spin to throw Lowry down after he latched on to the QB from behind right as Lowry began to slide.

Either way, both those penalties are assessed for another 20 yards and WMU is down into the red zone here after starting at its own 7.

Daniel Hull with a perfect punt

It wasn't pretty, but Daniel Hull delivered a strong punt that got downed at the WMU 7 yard line. It originally appeared to be 53 yards and downed at the 1, but it must've been touched sooner, so it'll be 47 yards and still downed inside the 10.

Elijha Payne banged up for EMU

On a 3rd and 13 scramble that saw Jace Stuckey come up short of the line to gain, EMU starting tackle Elijha Payne went down and had trainers come out and attend to him. He eventually got helped up and walked off under his own power, while appearing to stabilizing himself on a pair of coaches/trainers.

Payne went right to the tent on the EMU sideline.

Stuckey starts at QB for EMU

As expected based off warmups, Jace Stuckey gets the start at QB for EMU. His first play is a pass that's tipped an intercepted by Joey Pope, but it's waved off with a roughing the passer call as both Dalton Gustwiller and Dillon Moore hit Stuckey.

Gustwiller landed on top of the quarterback with a drive into the ground, likely bringing out the flag.

It's an early break with the flag for EMU, which was otherwise looking at two plays of disaster to start this game.

One play, one score, WMU leads 7-0

Jalen Buckley takes the opening carry basically untouched to the left for a 72-yard score. A late dive at his ankles down the sideline couldn't put him off course.

WMU now has TD runs of 82, 82 and 72 yards in each of the last three games, respectively.

Took all of eight seconds.

Eastern Michigan wins toss, defers

Western Michigan will start with the ball on offense in this one.

Of the questionable Broncos, Aveion Chenault and Justyce Betts both appear to have dressed out, while tight end Ryan Brotherton is wearing his jersey over sweats on the sideline, evidently not playing tonight.

Stuckey, not McCaughey, rolling with starters for EMU in warmups

As Eastern Michigan goes through the skeleton portion of warmups, with the quarterback throwing to receivers vs. the secondary and linebackers with no lines, it's Jace Stuckey rolling with the starting group of receivers and skill, as Brogan McCaughey is repping with the twos.

That trend continued with the offensive line during the full 11-on-11 warmup period, appearing to indicate that Stuckey will get the start.

McCaughey started the last two games in Kim's absence, as the fifth-year Yale transfer offered a steady hand and nearly led a comeback road win vs. Ohio but then struggled vs. Central Michigan.

Stuckey, a junior, has seen minimal game action in 2026, and hadn't played for the Eagles in his first two seasons. He threw a late touchdown pass vs. Central Michigan as the game was out of hand.

Pregame reading

Western Michigan prepping for EMU QB uncertainty ahead of key, penultimate MAC game
The Eagles head to Kalamazoo for a key MAC showdown, but who will play QB remains an open question vs. WMU.
Western Michigan's improving pass offense seeks more: ‘By no means a finished product’
The Broncos haven't produced a scintillating passing attack, but are better in a few pronounced, key ways to balance out the offense.
Week 11 picks, preview: MSU, UM face PNW foes while WMU-EMU face off at Waldo on Tuesday
All five FBS teams in the Mitten are back in action this weekend — and following week — with some notable B1G matchups and an in-state matchup in the MAC.