Yes! No. Maybe? Week 12 sees UM stellar on D again, MSU critically hurt, an 86 yard punt

There was a historic punt, a big upset, and plenty of other meaningful happenings and results around the FBS programs in Michigan this week.

Share
Yes! No. Maybe? Week 12 sees UM stellar on D again, MSU critically hurt, an 86 yard punt
(Via Central Michigan Athletics/Addison Glascock)

There was plenty of action and big results across the state of Michigan, from Western Michigan winning in MACtion to stay in the hunt in the MAC title race to Michigan upsetting UCLA on Senior Day to get bowl eligible. 

The Broncos beat Eastern Michigan in that game on Tuesday at Waldo Stadium, scuttling the Eagles’ faint bowl hopes while Central Michigan fell victim to Buffalo on the road. And Michigan State, hosting Oregon on Friday, got blown out with an incredibly injured lineup. 

Dig in to all the results, and recap an action-packed week while eying the regular season finales and beyond. 

Yes!

An 86 yards punt: In case you somehow missed it on Wednesday night in Buffalo, Declan Duley drilled an 86 yard punt for Central Michigan, as the Chippewas kicked from their own 13 and downed the punt just inside the Buffalo 1 yard line. And from where Duley was standing, the ball basically travelled 80 yards aerially before bouncing and rolling down to the 1, where gunner Da’Shon Febres calmly got around the ball and downed it. It was a key sequence at the time, flipping the field and then setting up CMU for a go-ahead touchdown (which would quickly get undone on defense.) It’s the longest punt in Central Michigan history, as Duley etches his place in the program record books, and the longest punt in the FBS in four seasons. Hard to possibly execute a play better on special teams. And in the social media furor around the play — the people love a punt — Duley’s own mom posted an edit shouting out long snapper Zach Curtis. 

Western Michigan’s rushing explosion: In each of its last three games, WMU has a rushing touchdown of at least 72 yards. That’s how far Jalen Buckley went on the first play from scrimmage against Eastern Michigan on Tuesday night. In the two prior games, Cole Cabana had a touchdown run of 82 yards in each game. And the ability to hit these home run rushing plays is a great club for the Broncos to have in their bag. Some of it is because defenses faltered on a run fight, but having the offensive line and backs to create huge holes and pay them off is a luxury, for certain — and one WMU has worked hard to have. And the Broncos are just one of 11 teams nationally to have three or more runs of 70-plus yards. 

WMU LB Dillon Moore: Built like the Terminator, Moore plays like one, too, for WMU. He’s the second-leading tackler on the team, just three off the pace set by fellow linebacker Justyce Betts, while leading WMU with three interceptions, adding 3.5 sacks (behind just Austin Alexander and Scoop Gardner Jr. on WMU; they each have 6) and a forced fumble. Moore had the interception on Bryce Underwood that was nearly a pick six in the opener, and then finally got one on an eerily similar play vs. EMU, jumping a route just before halftime down the sideline to the offenses right and running it back. He just didn’t step out of bounds this time. Moore is someone head coach Lance Taylor has raved about for the way the linebacker matured and grew off the field — and now it’s all paying off as Moore is the fearsome force in the middle of WMU’s defense. 

Michigan’s defense: There are not a dozen defenses in college football better than Michigan. The Wolverines have given up more than 21 points once all season, to Oregon, and turned around from that performance to beat UCLA into a pulp over four quarters and overtime at Michigan Stadium, turning the Bruins over three times, sacking the opposing quarterback four times, knocking Ty Dieffenbach out of the game and delivering a physically punishing performance that the Bruins for much of the season have tried to hand out. Chris Bracy had another interception, perfectly reading Dieffenbach’s eyes early to bail from his flat zone and undercut an out route. John Henry Daley had two sacks, including a sack fumble, and Trey Pierce recovered UCLA’s second lost fumble to give Michigan a 15-yard field to set up its lone regulation TD drive. Michigan’s defense almost held UCLA to 3 points, but the Bruins managed to get into the endzone on a last-gasp drive at the end of regulation. But then the Michigan defense turned around, Dieffenbach got hurt on the first play of OT, and the Bruins were cooked from there against Michigan’s defense. 

Free tickets: Western Michigan is giving away free tickets — up to 8, in sections around the respective redzones and endzones — for its home finale vs. Miami (OH). It’s a clever move, both for the fact the Broncos will want a raucous and packed crowd for a key MAC finale, that could propel WMU back to the conference title game. It’s also a smart gambit given a good MACtion crowd is usually just a shade more than 10,000 people. WMU had more than 20,000 people at each of its first four home games, which were all on Saturdays. Getting a big crowd in on Tuesday night, particularly as folks might want an excuse to get out of the house, or get the rest of their family out of the house is a smart marketing gambit for the Broncos. Should be a solid crowd for a meaningful game. 

No. 

EMU’s pick six, digging a hole: Chris Creighton said right after the game that EMU’s pick six just before half “didn’t need to happen.” While Dillon Moore might disagree, Creighton is right as far as his team was concerned. Down 24-7 and getting the ball on the other side of halftime and with less than a minute to go, EMU’s last Jace Stuckey-led drive of the day would’ve been fine to end in no points with the clock running. But Stuckey got predictable, threw a check down to the flat one too many times, and Moore was all over. And that touchdown more or less was the margin, because even if WMU didn’t kick a second-half field goal, it could’ve won 31-27. Maybe WMU plays a cleaner second half without the pick six, but it turned out to be the play that buried EMU, making the hole too deep to climb out of. 

WMU’s flat 2nd half: And on the other side, the Broncos were not pleased with the way the second half went, getting outscored 20-3 and barely gaining more than 102 yards. The Western Michigan coaches and players had talked in the locker room about coming out and still playing with fire and intensity in the second half, like the game was 0-0. That almost became something of a reality as EMU fought back to try and tie the game and complete the comeback, as WMU needed to come up with a 4th down blitz call to call game and end EMU’s shot at tying the game in the final minute. The first half was a shining example of how dominant WMU can be, and the second half is a warning of what can happen if they don’t finish games. And frankly, head coach Lance Taylor is happy to be able to reinforce that message and have his team with a chip on its shoulder. 

UM short yardage rushing: The Wolverines have just not been good rushing in short yardage this year, which is a stark departure from recent years, of course. There were some stark examples on Saturday vs. UCLA, too. Early, Michigan tried to go for it on 4th and 2 from around midfield and kept the ball in Bryce Underwood’s hands for a keeper, and he got swallowed up behind the line of scrimmage. Later in the game, as Michigan tried to score on a goal-to-go situation from the five, two carries to Savion Hiter went for 0 and -1 yards. And even earlier in the game, ahead of the 4th and 2 where Salesi Moa couldn’t haul in a pass, Michigan had 3rd and 1, handed to Hiter, and saw a swarm of defenders come through to drop him for a loss. It’s the sort of stuff that’s been quietly killing drives and the Michigan offense this year. 

MSU’s ability to overcome these injuries: This is not a “no” in the sense of poo-pooing how MSU has looked, but just acknowledging the reality that it’s functionally impossible to field a competitive football team against decent Big Ten competition in MSU’s current state. MSU is down to at best a hurt QB2 and started QB3 and true freshman Kayd Coffman against Oregon. Top defenders at all three levels — DL Ben Roberts, LB Jordan Hall, S Devin Vaught — were all out vs. the Ducks. And that only scratches the surface. This MSU team is fighting incredibly hard and is clearly bought in, but it’s just way too much of a M.A.S.H. unit to get the stops, first downs and scores needed to beat teams like Oregon, Washington and the like. Perhaps Rutgers in the finale is a reprieve, as MSU opened as a slight favorite.  

CMU’s rush defense: Messiah Burch may well win MAC offensive player of the year, and CMU watched the star receiver-turned-running back race away from its defense for much of the night as Burch racked up 200 yards on 24 carries and scored twice. His 75 yard touchdown run as CMU tried to keep pace in the second half ended up being the back breaker. As a whole, CMU gave up 283 yards on 44 carries with four rushing touchdowns. Central Michigan is down a number of front seven defenders, but even a banged up group would like to do better than CMU did on Wednesday in western New York as the game ran away from CMU. 

Maybe? 

There will be three bowl teams: Western Michigan is bowl eligible. Michigan, with the upset over UCLA, is bowl eligible. And all Central Michigan needs to do to get bowl eligible? Beat a Ball State team whose only three wins are an FCS team, Bowling Green in OT, and Sacramento State. While Central Michigan has struggled to beat teams better than it, this year, it has not had such issues dispatching teams it should beat. And with CMU’s offensive line and run game facing a Ball State squad allowing more than 190 yards game on the ground  — and which happens to be coached by one of Matt Drinkall’s close friends, Mike Uremovich — things are setting up well for the Chippewas to get a sixth win and go to back-to-back bowls to open Drinkall’s tenure. 

Michigan can beat Ohio State: It’s still not exactly clear how MIchigan will score, but it’s also not looking like Ohio State will be able to do much besides what it’s done for the past few weeks with Luke Fahey at quarterback: Chuck it up to Jeremiah Smith and pray. That legitimately might produce enough offense to beat Michigan, which still struggles badly to sustain drives and find the end zone. But before Julian Sayin got hurt and Ohio State descended into its own version of hell this year, it was pretty clear Michigan was cooked going into Columbus. That just isn’t the case anymore. Ohio State is still probably likely to win and just needs to cash in a few scores to really have Michigan in a bind. But it’s not hard to imagine Michigan’s defense doing enough to play this into a close game in the second half, where all the pressure is being refracted into a white hot beam of negative energy pointed at Ryan Day and the Buckeyes. It’s also the lowest win total between these two teams entering The Game this century. In 2011, 9-2 Michigan beat 6-5 Ohio State; in 2001, 6-4 Ohio State beat 8-2 Michigan. Those games had 15 and 14 combined wins between them, respectively. This year? It’s 13, as 6-5 Michigan visits 7-4 Ohio State. 

Michigan should’ve been using the tight ends all along: It did not appear that Michigan played a single snap of the Rhino personnel on Saturday vs. UCLA, and if it did it went largely unnoticed. Instead, Michigan got its tight end room thoroughly involved, with true freshman Mason Bonner catching the touchdown in regulation and Jalen Hoffman catching the game-winning conversion in triple overtime. All told, Michigan’s tight ends had five catches for 67 yards and the touchdown. That’s after having 24 for 238 in 10 prior games. It’s very easy to armchair quarterback and write revisionist history, but it’s not hard to imagine Michigan could’ve found better offensive fortunes by cutting bait on the Rhino packages and turning back to more 11, 12 and 13 personnel as the season went along. 

MSU can parlay dejection into hunger: Well, this has sucked, hasn’t it, Spartans? But if there’s one bit of optimism to have, it’s that this team has stuck together, fought, played hard and been every bit of a respectable team but for talent and health. Both of those things can be addressed in the offseason, as the Spartans heal up and Pat Fitzgerald and Co. mine the portal to make MSU look more like a Big Ten contender. And mixing the way MSU has been bought in with a desire to not feel this way again can be a powerful force to sustain an offseason of development and improvement. This season has been a disaster, but it doesn’t have to be for nothing — and that’s a choice the Spartans get to make over the next nine months. 

Kayd Coffman is MSU’s future at QB: The true freshman has had a pair of starts, and his second looked quite a bit better than his first, while still looking like a second career start. Par for the course, ultimately. But Coffman, a four-star signee from in-state East Kentwood High School, is a promising young player, and one MSU would be wise to invest in keeping. The Spartans love Alessio Milivojevic, especially for how he’s grown into a leader off the field, and presumably would love to have him back under center in 2027. It might take another year before Coffman has a shot at starting, and that’s a risky gambit in modern CFB with the ability to up stakes and transfer. Either way, he’s someone the Spartans would be wise to prioritize keeping, both for the future and for competent depth behind Milivojevic or whoever else might be at quarterback.