EMU injury, inconsistency bill comes due as comeback falls short, bowl hope scuttled vs. WMU
Eastern Michigan fell into too big a hole to come back vs. Western Michigan, a similar tale to much of its season.
KALAMAZOO — The interception before halftime, a pick six for Western Michigan that proved to be the margin in the game, didn’t need to happen.
That was head coach Chris Creighton’s main contention about the play with fewer than :10 to halftime, and EMU down 24-7 in the moment. It resulted in Jace Stuckey being pulled from the game at quarterback at halftime, as he’d struggled badly then compounded it with the pick six. The Eagles swapped in Brogan McCaughey, who delivered a 20-point second half that nearly brought Eastern Michigan back from a 24-point halftime deficit, but the shortcomings proved to be to much as EMU (4-7, 3-4) lost, 34-27, and will miss a bowl game for the third-straight year.
“So it was obviously a tough half, and very calmly, at halftime, we just said, ‘Look, we're... we're... absolutely gonna play this half,” Creighton said post game. “The right way, hard, together, smart. One play at a time. And we're gonna — there's no 21-point plays — we're gonna come back. And we're gonna come back, and they're gonna — their collars are gonna start to get tight, and there's gonna be a momentum switch, and we're gonna come back and win this game. And what we said at halftime didn't come true.”
And that’s been the story of the season for EMU: A team that could line up and be competitive in the MAC in spurts never did it consistently. Some of it is injury — EMU played five different starting offensive line combinations, hasn’t had QB Noah Kim healthy for two games, and missed myriad other contributors throughout the year — and a lot of it is inconsistency in how EMU has been, or not been, in games.
It means Eastern Michigan, now with seven losses, won’t make a bowl game for three straight years as Creighton winds down his 13th season leading the Eagles.
“There's seniors in there that know that they've got seven days left now,” Creighton said in the hallway outside the visitors locker room at Waldo Stadium. “And this is obviously — we’re not gonna be eligible for a bowl game. And although we didn't talk about it a lot, I know as I know, for myself and for everybody, that, you know, that was a big deal.”
Take Tuesday night vs. the Broncos at Waldo Stadium. The first half was the sort of bad spell that’s doomed this team lately, like early against Toledo as that game got out of hand, or against Central Michigan for basically the whole night, in what Creighton called a “humbling” performance.
Even early in the season, EMU won its opener over Sacramento State, but couldn’t follow that up by holding on to a lead at home against San Jose State in an eventual one-score loss. EMU got back on the winning track after back-to-back Big Ten losses, winning three-straight over Lindenwood, UMass and Akron.
EMU even could’ve pulled off a massive road win at Ohio, had the kickoff coverage unit not gotten creased and allowed a go-ahead kickoff return TD right after the Eagles took the lead late in the fourth quarter.
And that performance against Ohio, outside of the kickoff return TD, is a great encapsulation of what EMU was potentially capable of. The defense showed up with a stellar performance, continuing a year of improved results after being one of the worst FBS defense in 2025, holding Ohio and quarterback Nic Poulos to 17 offensive points and producing a scoop-and-score, while McCaughey, starting for an injured Kim for the first time, led a late go-ahead drive and then nearly another, after the kick return TD.


And while the shine as come off UMass, when EMU went there in Week 5, and got to play one of its healthiest games of the year, the Eagles shredded the Minutemen, as the defense smothered a dangerous quarterback into a middling pocket passer and Noah Kim and Co. sizzled on offense.
A gritty late comeback win and surviving a missed field goal from Akron was a reason to celebrate, too.
Those moments, though, were fleeting.
And against WMU, that tale of two halves might’ve been the difference in the game, as the Stuckey-led Eagles couldn’t find any offensive footing the first half, only scoring a touchdown because of a muffed punt recovered at the WMU 8 yard line.
McCaughey came in and delivered in the second half, as EMU flashed the upside to go toe-to-toe with a MAC contender, beating up WMU on defense while the offense came alive on the ground and through the air as the backup QB found the likes of tight end Josh Long and receivers Harold Mack and Nick Devereaux downfield. Running back Amareon Blue had three touchdowns and was EMU’s first 100 yard rusher for the season.
“We were probably a little frustrated with the pick six,” Creighton said. “It just, that didn't need to happen. You know, I'm not trying to put all that on Jace and whatnot. But, he was completing balls, but we weren't throwing the ball downfield. But we certainly don't ever want to force things downfield. But when we thought maybe there was a couple times that we could have thrown the ball downfield, and so I just thought we'd get Brogan a shot in that regard.”
McCaughey went 12-of-16 for 135 yards and a touchdown as EMU chiseled down the margin in the second half.
But it wasn’t enough to get out of the hole EMU dug itself.
“Tough locker room,” Creighton said to open his post game comments. “Tough locker room.”
And injuries, surely, played a major factor in EMU’s struggles.
That it was Stuckey starting and McCaughey replacing him at QB is the obvious place to start, as EMU last saw starter Noah Kim on the field against Toledo on Oct. 17., as Kim has since been out with an undisclosed injury.
The Eagles have also been without, at various points, every starting offensive lineman but center Nic Gallegos.
LT Tyler Brumfield, LG Guzzy Kayed, RG Cole Dellinger and RT Elijha Payne have all missed at least one game. Devereaux, a top wideout, missed four games, and Mack missed one. Safety Jason Marshall has missed three games, cornerback Caleb Coley has missed eight and linebacker Barry Manning has been out for the season since Week 1.
It’s been a revolving door, too, as someone gets back only for seemingly one more player to get hurt.
No one on the Eagles’ staff or locker room is using the health situation as an excuse, but it’s also impossible to ignore the fact the Eagles haven’t been able to roll out a consistent lineup and develop continuity.
It’s been too many missteps, too many injuries, and too many big holes — including a 24-point one on Tuesday — to dig out of.
Mitten Football is a reader supported publication aiming to bring independent coverage of FBS college football in Michigan, with a particular focus on the Michigan MAC teams. Considering subscribing for $8 a month (or $87 a year, or for free) to support this work. And consider sharing Mitten Football — referrals from trusted sources are the strongest endorsement.

